Medford, New York · Long Island

Mill Pond Golf Course

Buddy Johnson's 1999 links-style layout on 200-plus acres, where the fescue plays as a hazard and every lake is lateral.

Get tee time alertsCourse websiteMore Long Island courses

About Mill Pond Golf Course

Mill Pond is a links-style course in Medford, on more than 200 acres. William "Buddy" Johnson designed it and it opened in 1999. Think fescue and open ground, not a walk through the trees. Only 7 of the 18 holes are tree-lined. Course character from OpenStreetMap contributors' survey data.

The map data shows plenty of hazards: 73 bunkers across the course, water on six holes, and four forced carries over it. Six holes bend, three each way. Fescue is played as a hazard here, so a miss wide of the fairway can cost you a stroke. Club down off the tee if you're spraying it. Course character from OpenStreetMap contributors' survey data.

Audubon International recognizes the course for environmental excellence. The practice setup is solid: a short-game area, a practice bunker, a putting green matched to the course greens and a covered hitting area. There's also a simulator, and the Grill Room and terrace look out over the course.

It's one of 46 courses Yoink watches in the Long Island area, and the closest alternative is Middle Island Country Club, about 2 miles away — handy when your first choice is booked solid.

What it's like to play Mill Pond Golf Course

You'll carry water off the tee or into the green on 4 holes. There are about 73 bunkers out there, well above average, so a good bunker game pays. A creek or river runs through the property and comes into play on 4 holes.

Course character from OpenStreetMap contributors' survey data (ODbL).

Booking a tee time at Mill Pond Golf Course

Tee times go online up to 7 days ahead, with a $3 fee on advance reservations. Check in 30 minutes early or you can lose the slot. In 2026 in-season (4/20 to 10/12), weekdays are $56 walking or $79 riding before 1:52pm; weekends are $73 or $96. Carts are required before 1pm Friday to Sunday. Brookhaven residents can buy a two-year resident card at the pro shop for lower rates. Off-season pricing starts 10/13/26.

Booking window and green fees at Mill Pond Golf Course

Booking window. On the online tee sheet Yoink reads, each new day's tee times appear 7 days ahead just after midnight. That held on 15 of the 18 new days we tracked (Sep 14 to 29, 2026). Residents, members or cardholders may be able to book earlier, so check the course's own policy.

Green fees. For 18 holes, most tee times on the booking page were listed at $53.15 to $97.15, and the middle price was $80.15. That's from 1,471 tee times dated Sep 13 to Oct 6, 2026. Prices change with the season, the day and the time, and can differ for residents. Whether a cart is included depends on the course.

How to get a tee time at Mill Pond Golf Course

Yoink

If Mill Pond Golf Course looks full for the day you want, it usually isn't for long: groups drop, rounds get moved and times reopen at all hours.

Yoink checks the sheet for you. Set a watch for the date, window and group size you want, and you'll get a push notification as soon as a spot opens — then book it directly with Mill Pond Golf Course.

  1. Pick Mill Pond Golf Course in Yoink.
  2. Choose your day, time window and number of players.
  3. Get an alert when a matching tee time opens — then book it directly with the course.
Get tee time alertsFree during the beta · You always book direct with the course

Golf courses near Mill Pond Golf Course

All 46 Long Island courses in New York · New York golf courses

Mill Pond Golf Course FAQ

Where is Mill Pond Golf Course?

Mill Pond Golf Course is in Medford, New York, in the Long Island area — about 2 miles from Middle Island Country Club.

Who designed Mill Pond Golf Course, and when did it open?

Mill Pond Golf Course was designed by William "Buddy" Johnson and opened in 1999.

Is Mill Pond Golf Course open to the public?

Mill Pond Golf Course is Town of Brookhaven residents get discounted fees with a Mill Pond Resident Card valid two years.

Can you walk Mill Pond Golf Course?

Carts required before 1pm Friday-Sunday (2026 in-season).

How far in advance can you book a tee time at Mill Pond Golf Course?

On the online tee sheet Yoink tracks, new tee times at Mill Pond Golf Course appear 7 days ahead just after midnight. That held on 15 of the 18 new days we tracked (Sep 14 to 29, 2026). Resident or member windows can be earlier; the course's booking page has the official policy.

How much does it cost to play Mill Pond Golf Course?

For 18 holes, most tee times Yoink saw on the booking page were listed at $53.15 to $97.15 (middle price $80.15), from 1,471 tee times dated Sep 13 to Oct 6, 2026. Prices vary by day, time, season and residency.

How many holes is Mill Pond Golf Course, and what's par?

Mill Pond Golf Course is an 18-hole regulation course: 18 holes, par 70, 6,304 yards.

How do I get a tee time at Mill Pond Golf Course when it's booked up?

Set a watch for Mill Pond Golf Course in Yoink with your date, time window and group size. Yoink monitors the course's tee sheet and alerts you the moment a matching time opens, including cancellations. You book directly with the course.

What golf courses are near Mill Pond Golf Course?

Nearby options include Middle Island Country Club, Holbrook Country Club and Spy Ring Golf Club - Spy Ring. Yoink watches 46 courses in the Long Island area.

Sources

Facts on this page come from these pages, checked 2026-09-29. Rates and booking rules change, so confirm with the course.

Never miss a tee time at Mill Pond Golf Course

Yoink watches the tee sheet so you don't have to. When a time you want opens up, your phone buzzes — you book direct.

Get tee time alerts