Middle Island, New York · Long Island

Middle Island Country Club

Public, despite the name, on 225 acres of the old Lustgarten Nursery. Pair the Dogwood and Oak Tree nines and it runs 7,034 yards from the tips.

Get tee time alertsCourse websiteMore Long Island courses

About Middle Island Country Club

Middle Island is a public course with a country-club name, set about as close to the middle of Long Island as you can get. It was carved out of 225 acres of the old Lustgarten Nursery and has been in play since 1965. It's three nines, Spruce, Oak Tree and Dogwood, played in 18-hole pairs, so ask which two are in rotation when you book.

They aren't the same length. Dogwood (par 36) is the longest at 3,561 yards from the championship tees, with two par 5s pushing 600. Oak Tree (par 36) runs 3,473, and Spruce (par 35) 3,417, a bit more with the alternate tees on its 6th and 8th. Put Dogwood and Oak Tree together and you get a par 72 of 7,034 yards from the back, with men's, senior and ladies' tees well forward of that.

A few house rules to know: two to a cart, no private carts, no outside coolers, and kids have to be 10 to play.

It's one of 46 courses Yoink watches in the Long Island area, and the closest alternative is Mill Pond Golf Course, about 2 miles away — handy when your first choice is booked solid.

Booking a tee time at Middle Island Country Club

Tee times open 7 days ahead. Online booking is for 18 holes with a cart; to walk, call the shop at (631) 924-3000. Give at least 24 hours' notice to change or cancel, since there are no refunds inside 24 hours, and the course may pair you up to fill a foursome.

How to get a tee time at Middle Island Country Club

Yoink

Golfers across Long Island know the drill: the good times at courses like Middle Island Country Club are gone within minutes of release, and cancellations come back without warning.

Instead of refreshing the booking page, let Yoink do it. Pick Middle Island Country Club, choose your day and time window, and Yoink alerts you when a tee time that fits opens up. You always book straight with the course.

  1. Pick Middle Island Country Club in Yoink.
  2. Choose your day, time window and number of players.
  3. Get an alert when a matching tee time opens — then book it directly with the course.
Get tee time alertsFree during the beta · You always book direct with the course

Golf courses near Middle Island Country Club

All 46 Long Island courses in New York · New York golf courses

Middle Island Country Club FAQ

Where is Middle Island Country Club?

Middle Island Country Club is in Middle Island, New York, in the Long Island area — about 2 miles from Mill Pond Golf Course.

When did Middle Island Country Club open?

Middle Island Country Club opened in In play since 1965.

Is Middle Island Country Club open to the public?

Middle Island Country Club is public daily-fee.

Can you walk Middle Island Country Club?

No beverage coolers on the course.

How many holes is Middle Island Country Club, and what's par?

Middle Island Country Club is a 27-hole golf facility: 27 holes, par 71, 7,113 yards.

How do I get a tee time at Middle Island Country Club when it's booked up?

Set a watch for Middle Island Country Club in Yoink with your date, time window and group size. Yoink monitors the course's tee sheet and alerts you the moment a matching time opens, including cancellations. You book directly with the course.

What golf courses are near Middle Island Country Club?

Nearby options include Mill Pond Golf Course, Rolling Oaks Golf Course and Willow Creek Golf & Country Club. Yoink watches 46 courses in the Long Island area.

Sources

Facts on this page come from these pages, checked 2026-09-29. Rates and booking rules change, so confirm with the course.

Never miss a tee time at Middle Island Country Club

Yoink watches the tee sheet so you don't have to. When a time you want opens up, your phone buzzes — you book direct.

Get tee time alerts